Choosing the Best Bed Guard

Last updated: February 12, 2017

If you have ever been awakened by a screaming child who just rolled out of bed, then you've probably wondered what the best bed guard is for preventing this from ever happening again. There is nothing worse or more startling than hearing your child afraid and in pain after a fall, especially when that fall happens in the middle of the night.

To prevent this from happening, guards can be attached to your child's bed so that he or she remains safe and sound throughout the night, no matter how much they might roll around in their sleep. These products are completely safe if used properly, as outlined in this consumer report. With so many different products on the market, it can be challenging to decide what bed guard is the most helpful and safe for your child. To make the decision easier, we have put together reviews for three great products we think you are going to love.


Best Bed Guard

Regalo Swing Down Bedrail

Regalo Hide Away Extra Long Bed Rail

Best Bed Guard

Hiccapop Foam Bed Bumpers






  1. Durable and strong steel construction
  2. 43 inches long, 20 inches tall
  3. Washable mesh wall
  4. Swing-down design
  1. 54 inches long, 20 inches tall
  2. Hideaway design
  3. Durable and strong steel construction
  4. Washable mesh wall
  1. Comfortable foam construction
  2. Waterproof cover
  3. 52 inches long, 4.5 inches tall
  4. Machine-washable cover

Regalo Swing Down Bedrail

  • Durable and strong steel construction
  • 43 inches long, 20 inches tall
  • Washable mesh wall
  • Swing-down design
Best Bed Guard

The Regalo Swing Down Bedrail is a fantastic option for toddlers who sleep in a twin, full, or queen sized bed. Its durable construction, simple setup process, ease of use, and washable materials make it stand out from its competitors.

The railing has been constructed entirely of steel, so you don't have to worry about your child knocking it down as they move in their sleep or accidentally breaking it. This bed rail is strong enough to do exactly what it was made for - preventing your little loved one from falling out of bed. When your child is up during the day, this bed rail can swing down and out of the way easily, without having to be completely removed.

Because the railing is 43 inches long, it is large enough to prevent your child from falling around the sides of it. Additionally, this bed guard features Regalo's patented Gap Guard system, which holds the railing firmly against the mattress so nothing and nobody can slip through.

The steel railing is covered with a removable layer of fabric and mesh. The fabric is a strong nylon blend, which is comfortable and soft enough to lean up against but durable enough to handle a good amount of weight against it. If something is spilled on this cover, it can simply be wiped away with a damp cloth or paper towel. When a deeper cleaning is necessary, the cover can be removed and thrown in the washer and dryer.


  • Simple setup that requires no tools
  • Easy clean-up for busy parents and messy kids
  • Swing-down function allows for bed to be easily made
  • Works on multiple bed sizes
  • Simple to use
  • Great bed rails for toddlers


  • Not tall enough for most pillow-top mattresses

Regalo Hide Away Extra Long Bed Rail

  • 54 inches long, 20 inches tall
  • Hideaway design
  • Durable and strong steel construction
  • Washable mesh wall

This Hide Away Extra Long Bed Rail is another fantastic and effective option from Regalo that we think parents will find useful. It has a lot in common with the bed guard we listed above, but this variation can be completely hidden instead of just swung down. Additionally, this option is even longer than the one mentioned above.

The railing on this bed guard has been constructed entirely of steel, so you know it isn't going to break or give out due to any force your child applies to it. There is no way your child is going to fall out of their bed with this product protecting them. At times when the guard is not in use, it actually slides completely underneath the mattress. This is great for parents who don't want the eyesore a bed rail can become and for children who like to relax and play in their beds during the day.

This bed guard is extra long and measures 54 inches. It's a great option for older children or those who may be exceptionally tall. Regardless, it offers superior protection over the shorter options. Like the option above, this bed guard features Regalo's patented Gap Guard system, which holds the railing firmly against the mattress so nothing and nobody can slip through.

Similar to the Swing Away variation, the Hide Away toddler bed rails feature a removable layer of fabric and mesh that is strong, easy to clean, and removable.


  • Extra-long for additional protection
  • Durable and strong
  • Easy to clean
  • Simple setup requires no tools
  • Hidden completely out of sight while not in use
  • Great toddler bed rails


  • Too long for toddler beds
  • Not tall enough for most pillow-top matresses

Hiccapop Foam Bed Bumpers

  • Comfortable foam construction
  • Waterproof cover
  • 52 inches long, 4.5 inches tall
  • Machine-washable cover
Best Bed Guard

The Foam Bed Bumpers from Hiccapop are a unique variation on bed guards. While they are the most expensive option on this list, we feel that their comfort and effectiveness make them a worthwhile consideration for parents. Rather than rigid barriers that hook to the bed, Hiccapop features two foam bumpers that can be placed right underneath a fitted sheet on both sides of the bed.

The bumpers are 54 inches long and constructed with a firm and comfortable foam. They are soft enough to never cause discomfort while remaining firm enough to keep your child from rolling over them. These bumpers do away with the caged-in feeling that taller and more rigid bed guards can create. Additionally, the foam guards allow for parents to easily climb in and out of a child's bed without having to move anything.

Each of the two bumpers features a removable cover that busy parents can throw in the wash along with all other bedding.


  • No real setup - just tuck under fitted sheet
  • Washable and removable covers
  • Comes as a pair
  • No caged-in feeling
  • Doesn't make getting in and out of bed difficult
  • Extremely comfortable


  • May require buying larger fitted sheets

Best Bed Guard Conclusion

Choosing a product from an overwhelming number of options, especially for children you want to protect and buy the best for, can be challenging. That is why we hope the above three options take some of the guesswork out of buying the best bed guard for your little loved one at home. These products may be a good option for the elderly or ill as well, as suggested in the FDA's statement about bed rails. What matters most is that the guard is effective at preventing falls and is safe in all conditions. Other than that, choosing the best bed guard variation that fits your family should be simple.

Best Pick: Regalo Swing Down Bedrail

Best Bed Guard

Leave a Comment: